Publications > Publication
Tatarstan. An independent territory making the most of its natural resources

Universal News, Inc.

Special Report on The Russian Federation, February 15th, 1999, pp. 11-14


      Tatarstan President Mintimer Shaimiev says: "Today we are the true owners of all the wealth in our country."
      Tatarstan is proud of its long history - even if the name 'Tatar' still strikes fear in the subconscious of many Russians and other Europeans.
      Islamic since the 10th century, Tatarstan was later annexed by Gengiz Khan, to become part of

TATARSTAN
Photo: Dragoljub Zamurovic


the powerful Golden Horde state.
      Subsequent incorporation into Tsarist and Soviet Russia left many Tatars unhappy with their lot, though their capital, Kazan, became a major industrial center and transport hub. Then oil and gas brought added prosperity, and the collapse of Communism opened the way to a degree of autonomy unthinkable within most federal systems.
 

 

TATARSTAN

AN INDEPENDENT TERRITORY MAKING THE MOST OF ITS NATURAL RESOURCES

 

Republic has freedom within the Federation

Tatarstan enjoys almost total control over ils internal affairs and its vast energy reserves

bulak d.jpg (12046 bytes)

Among the various republics, regions and other territories which make up the complex Russian Federation, the Republic of Tatarstan has attained one of the highest degrees of autonomy. But it has stopped short of declaring full independence.
     Tatarstan's President, Mintimer Shaimiev, explains what happened at the time of the break-up of the old Soviet Union, when republics from Ukraine and Moldova in the West to Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan in the East opted to go their own way.
     "All the streets and squares were full of people shouting the slogan 'independence'. So I went out and made a speech, and asked them to be calm - but I didn't pronounce the word

Shaimiev:    Akoulov:
prepared     stable 

Shaimiev akoulov d.jpg (6172 bytes)


'independence'. It would have led to a real confrontation and even to war," the President says.
     Mr Shaimiev indicated at the time that he was prepared to negotiate and sign a treaty with the Russian Federation, and now Tatarstan governs almost all of its own internal affairs, and even has the right to develop international relations independently of Moscow. However, the Russian Federation keeps control of military factories on Tatarstan territory, as well as higher education. It also receives half of the monies raised from value added tax.

Political affairs

     The President's adviser on political affairs, Raphael Khakimov, says the government has not gone any further than that for several reasons.
     "First of all, the Tatarstan Republic is situated within the Russian Federation, and has no external borders.


And secondly, there is the ethnic problem.
     "Many Tatars live outside Tatarstan, in other parts of the Russian Federation, and it is impossible to break relations with those who live in the Republic."
     Tatars only slightly outnumber Russians, and there are more than 60 minority nationalities.
      Tatarstan has the huge advantage of being oil-rich. This means, for example, that it can proclaim an official minimum wage that is four times that of Russia's.
      But the government is keen not to depend too much on oil. Dr. Khakimov says: "We know that oil is an opportunity for us to survive the transition period. That's why we are trying to develop not only the oil industry, but also other industries, starting with equipment for extracting oil."
      Agriculture is still important too, with over a quarter of the population of less than four million living off the land.

President Shaimiev is taking a more cautious approach to economic reform than that of Moscow.
     "In 1992, when the radical reforms began, we said we were also in favor of reforms, but we were against so-called Уshock-therapyФ. We were criticized then for conservatism. But I said we would adopt reforms step by step and because of that, we didn't see a big drop in living standards."
      On official visits overseas President Shaimiev has raised people's awareness about Tatarstan and its special status. His international advisor, Timour Akulov, says there are many reasons why foreign investors are attracted to the Republic.
     "First, there's a very developed material-technical base and a huge scientific potential. Secondly, it is a stable political and social environment. Also, the legislative base of our republic is much better developed than in any other region of the Russian Federation," he says.

SUVAR so good: Tatarstan oil continues to attract foreign investors

One of the most practical benefits that Tatarstan gained through the autonomy agreement reached with the Russian Federation was the greater control it won over its oil industry and revenues.
     Though oil is notoriously vulnerable to price fluctuations on the world market, the Republic's Minister for Economy and Industry, Rinat Gubaidullin, is optimistic about the prospects in this sector. "There are favorable conditions for the export of oil, as with other export-oriented production, because of the devaluation of the rouble," he says.

Moreover, oil is a sector foreign banks and investors are interested in. "The financing of the republic's construction project for a new oil-refining plant to process seven million tons of oil a year is maintained thanks to a 115 million dollar credit received from Citibank, with a guarantee from Eximbank in the US," he adds.

Tatarstan has had to set up or reform oil-related companies and institutions in order to deal with the changed situation.


One such is SUVAR, which acts as a government agent to sell oil both within the Russian internal market and abroad.  It thus works closely with the main producing company TatNeft.

SUVAR's General Director Boris Chub says: "TatNeft didn't have any department within it that was working with exports, but we had a license for exporting oil. So we proposed ourselves as a possible exporter, based on experience of working with many cities and regions within the Russian Federation."

He adds: "Although 12 companies from Tatarstan were seeking that position, we survived the competition, and from 1993 began trading oil as the monopolists in that market.

"Rather that put all their eggs in one basket however, SUVAR did not limit its operations to working with TatNeft, despite the fact that was for some time such a profitable arrangement. Mr Chub says: "We also worked a lot with a Moscow oil-refinery, and the Kremenchuge oil-refinery. Currently, we are working with the metallurgical complexes of Russia and Ukraine."


Such diversification proved wise. Mr Chub says: "When the situation in the oil-petro market got harder, our company did not collapse, in spite of the fact that the turnover dropped.

"Nowadays, we export about three million tons together with TatNeft. Germany and the United States are the main markets.

"Chase Manhattan granted TatNeft a credit of 156 million dollars, and we work as operators of this credit, which means that we provide oil to the company appointed by Chase Manhattan Bank."

Current climate

In the current climate, it is difficult to open up new markets for oil. And there is the added hindrance of competing with the biggest international companies.

Mr. Chub says. "If you compare TatNeft with Shell, for example, you can see the difference in the rating of their shares.

"Nevertheless, over the last three years, TatNeft's stock has increased a lot in value."


Mr Chub wants to start working seriously in industrial production but there are obstacles to overcome. He says: "We have made attempts to produce, but existing laws in this country do not let production develop effectively: there is very high taxation, most of which are so-called 'undercover' taxes, which make the primary cost of the product rather high.

"We also understand that our products here are of a lower quality than their equivalents in Western countries. In consequence, foreign investors are not attracted to the productive sphere."

Mr Chub hopes that situation can be resolved by transferring the tax burden from the producer to other sectors in the chain of production, and cutting taxes as a whole.

Chub: production
Chub: production


Petrochemicals giant set to expand

New technology and joint ventures have helped Nizhnekamskneftekhim to increase its production capacity

Tatarstan is home to the largest petrochemical company in Europe, bearing the tongue-twisting name (for Westerners) of Nizhnekamskneftekhim. Based in the republic's third city, Nizhnekamsk, the company has more than 16,500 people on its payroll.
     Exporting to over 20 countries, Nizhnekamskneftekhim manufactures a range of products, from butyl rubber, ethylene and propylene to styrene and polyether tars.
     Managing Director Rinat Galiev attributes much of the company's growth over the past 30 years to a strategy of  'quality, quantity and low prime cost'. The use of surplus stocks of products such as styrene and butadiene as raw material input has facilitated the relatively low-cost development of new product ranges.
     At the same time, technological processes are constantly being renewed and refined, much of the necessary research and development being done at the company's own Science and Technology Center
.

Raw materials

     Mr Galiev says: "The most important goal today is to increase our capacities through the introduction of new technologies, the deeper processing of raw materials and by more automation of the whole process."
     Some of the modernization currently going on at Nizhnekamskneftekhim has been made possible by foreign credit, but Mr Galiev is cautious about letting the company take on too much debt.
     He says: "We are very careful about questions of credit and investments because, to my mind, an investment is a debt, which you ought to pay back some day."
     Nonetheless, joint ventures of various kinds are playing an important role in the company's strategy. Mr Galiev says the company has had a positive experience with Petrokam, a joint venture between the Tatarstan Republic and Germany, producing ethylene glycol. Antifreeze is also produced through a joint venture, this time with an American firm, and US assistance is helping the construction of hydrocleansing installations too.
     Nizhnekamskneftekhim has a representative office in New York. Mr Galiev says: "We would like to win markets in Canada through our representation in the US. Currently, we sell more than 1,000 tons of rubber per month on the American continent. The only problem we have is a lack of products on that market. That is why we are increasing our capacity annually."

 Domestically however, the company has had to confront other difficulties. "We don't have a stable political and economic situation in Russia,"

Rubber plant : over 1,000 tons of rubber are exported to the US each month

Nizhnek d.jpg (17179 bytes)

says Mr Galiev. "We have had to make huge outlays because of the collapse of the banking system, and the changes in government.

Galiev: outlays
galiev d.jpg (2746 bytes)

     "Nevertheless, we have been able lo work thanks to the more or less stable situation in the Tatarstan Republic. This h,is really been possible because the republic's government helps in stabilizing industry here, and takes all due measures in order to keep a stable position."
     Another advantage Nizhnekamskneftekhim enjoys is its geographical location. Less than 10 miles away from the enterprise's industrial zone there is a dry cargo river terminal, with access to waterways that are open for navigation from May through November.
     Liquids are mainly transported by rail, with many of the railway tank wagons traveling to Kotka in Finland, where there are storage tanks for the transshipment of products such as propylene oxide, the development of which has been a particular personal interest of Rinat Galiev.

Environmental protection

     Acutely conscious of the dangers that can be associated with the petrochemical industry, Nizhnekamskneftekhim has installed a range of environmental protection facilities. The company uses an advanced water recircula-tion system, and the industrial complex has its own sewage disposal.
     New technology has been developed and introduced to collect and render harmless gaseous emissions, as well as employing biotreatment to deal with highly polluted waste water.


United banks bring renewed confidence
Sum is larger than the parts for a financial sector that is continuing to expand

Shortly after Tsar Alexander II decreed the setting up of the State Bank of the Russian Empire in 1860, a branch was opened in Kazan, now capital of Tatarstan. Even then, the area was key to the economic and cultural development of central Russia, and the bank was used as the gold depot for Russia. After the Communist Revolution of 1917, the bank was transformed into the State Bank of the USSR, with all relevant major policy settled in Moscow. But the situation changed dramatically in 1994, when an agreement was signed between the Russian State Bank and what had become the National Bank of the Tatarstan Republic.

Big is beautiful: Ak Bars Bank, set up in 1993, is the largest in Tatarstan
akbars d.jpg (10407 bytes)


Bogachev: powers
bogachev d.jpg (2996 bytes)

     The National Bank's President, Evgeny Bogachev, says: "We got many plenary powers due to the agreement, specifically we can fix rates ourselves. We can issue our own promisory notes and cheques. We have extended rights of control, registration and inspection. But we are not completely independent from the Bank of the Russian Federation."
     The National Bank's main aims are to promote the reorganization of the economy, the further development of the economic structure and the maintenance of the Republic's economic life.
     The enhanced autonomy Tatarstan has enjoyed in recent years has opened up new areas of banking and financial cooperation
abroad as well. Minister of Economy and Industry, Rinat Gubaidullin, says: "We have the right to conclude trade and economic agreements with foreign countries independently, to participate in the work of international economic and financial organizations, to attract government, bank and commercial credits with the guarantees of the government of Tatarstan, and to create free economic zones on the territory of the Republic."
     As in many parts of the Russian Federation, however, the banking sector has undergone some difficult times, and the total number of local banks has declined by a quarter, to about 30.
     Mr Gubaidullin says: "One of the measures for overcoming the crisis is uniting the forces of a group of banks - Ak Bars Bank, Tatfond Bank, Volzhsko-Kamski Bank-to provide mutual support and help."

Idrisov: principles
idrisov d.jpg (2612 bytes)

     Ak Bars Bank is the largest bank in Tatarstan, indeed third in the Russian Federation in terms of authorized capital and seventh in terms of total assets. Yet is a young institution, set up only in 1993. Il is authorized lo hold the gold reserves of the Republic of Tatarstan, and since 1998 has a general license for currency operations.
     Ak Bars Bank's Chairman, Mudaris Idrisov, fluently produces a list of statistics: "Ak Bars Bank has 34 representations, with 11 branches in different regions of Tatarstan and other republics. We are also expecting lo set up 23 new offices all over the Russian Federation. So we continue working on expanding our system, and hope to do so in the future."

High level

Nonetheless, the bank has not been able to avoid the effects of what  is going on in other parts of the Russian Federation. "Being the subject of Russia, Ak Bars Bank feels that crisis itself," Mr Idrisov says. "That's why we have to amend our strategy and principles. It is impossible today to plan for the next few years."
     However, Mr Idrisov is far from gloomy. "The main goal for us today is to restore the confidence of investors. The image of the Tatarstan Republic is on quite a high level, and we would like to confirm it."
     He is particularly keen to see greater links with the US. "I study everything that is happening in the United States attentively," he says. "Frankly, I like that country very much and I like the people living there. They are an open people, and when I'm abroad, I always recognize them immediately!"

This supplement has been prodused by Universal News Inc. The editors of U.S. News & World Report did not participate in its preparation and beer no responsibility for its content

Special Report on The Russian Federation, Universal News, Inc. February 15th, 1999, pp. 11-14